5 WWE stars who can retire AJ Lee for good

AJ Lee was involved in an incredible storyline with Becky Lynch that began last year upon her WWE homecoming. The feud culminated at WrestleMania 42 and right after that, The Black Widow disappeared into the shadows. However, she recently made an Instagram post, featuring behind-the-scenes moments with fellow WWE superstars. That post was filled with heartfelt gratitude as Lee thanked everyone who was part of her recent journey.

However, the tone of her words suggests that her time as an active competitor may be nearing its final chapter. Although AJ Lee hinted that she would return soon, the underlying message seems clear that the clock is ticking. A retirement is seemingly looming on the horizon. If this is truly the beginning of the end, the question becomes who could step up to deliver a career-defining farewell to the former Divas Champion in WWE.

Here are five WWE superstars who can retire AJ Lee:

#5. Lyra Valkyria

Lyra Valkyria is one of the rising stars of the current women’s division and she is also the inaugural Women’s Intercontinental Champion. The 29-year-old has been a beloved fan favorite on the main roster. She holds sheer potential to do great things as a singles star. Valkyria is one of the rightful contenders to retire AJ Lee and solidify herself as a big name in the current landscape of WWE.

The company can very well build it as a generational clash. Lyra defeating a legend like AJ in a high-stakes bout would validate her as a top-tier performer while giving The Black Widow a respectful exit from her in-ring career. It will therefore also showcase the evolution of women’s wrestling, marking a passing of the torch moment in the Stamford-based promotion.

#4. Bayley

Bayley offers deep historical and emotional weight, as she faced a young AJ Lee over a decade ago in NXT for the Divas Championship. Their 2026 encounter on Monday Night Raw tapped into that very history and connected WWE’s present and past. However, it was just a random match. The company needs to pull the trigger on a massive character change for The Role Model.

A heel Bayley should start a blockbuster feud with AJ and be the one to retire the former Divas Champion. The Role Model finally defeating the veteran and that too in a way where she gets to put her career to rest would feel poetic. This would give Bayley her long-awaited spotlight and most importantly, it will also close the history between her and her best friend.

#3. Liv Morgan

Liv Morgan is another name who can retire the legendary AJ Lee. The Miracle Kid has been on a phenomenal run in WWE, as she is currently standing at the top of the women’s division, holding the Women’s World Championship. A clash between Lee and Morgan is viewed as a dream bout among fans and the Stamford-based promotion might pull the trigger on that sooner or later.

Triple H might give Liv Morgan the utmost privilege to retire the former Divas Champion. Such a monumental moment will be a major career highlight for The Judgment Day member that will elevate her to a whole new level. There is no doubt that it would provide AJ Lee a dramatic, memorable send-off against a peer who embodies the current women’s division’s grit.

#2. Sol Ruca

Sol Ruca recently made her main roster debut on Monday Night Raw after making a name for herself in NXT. There is no doubt that her future is bright and she is destined for incredible things. The 26-year-old is one of the rightful contenders to give AJ Lee a memorable farewell match. Retiring the multi-time women’s champion would elevate Ruca to the main-event level.

This could work as a springboard for her rise to the very top of the women’s division. The amount of exposure Sol Ruca would get after retiring a legendary star like AJ would be unparalleled and WWE can legitimately make her a star out of this moment. This victory alone will showcase Ruca as a future main-eventer, capable of carrying the women’s division on her back.

#1. Roxanne Perez can retire AJ Lee

The name that stands at the top of the list to retire The Black Widow is Roxanne Perez. The Prodigy cited AJ Lee as a major inspiration since her early days and began her pro wrestling while idolizing the veteran. Interestingly, Perez is widely considered Lee’s wrestling daughter in a fun and affectionate way due to the history the two superstars have in real life.

And this makes the perfect connection for a meaningful storyline payoff in WWE. Roxanne Perez retiring the very person whom she grew up watching and idolizing will give rise to a poetic moment in the world of pro wrestling. This will truly mark a clash between two generational talents where AJ Lee can pass the torch to her prodigy before riding off into the sunset.